As a potential criminal defendant, it is vital to grasp the inner workings of evidence disclosure in criminal cases. Below, we will delve into the responsibilities of prosecutors in sharing evidence that could either bolster your defense or challenge the credibility of government witnesses. By gaining a deeper understanding of these obligations, you will be better equipped to navigate the legal system and protect your rights.
Facing criminal charges in New Jersey? Don’t go it alone. Contact The Law Offices of Jonathan F. Marshall at (877) 534-7338 or online for a powerful defense. With over 200 years of combined experience, our team of 11 criminal defense attorneys, including former prosecutors, will fight for the best outcome for you. We’re proud to have attorneys recognized by the National Trial Lawyers and Super Lawyers Rising Stars. Trust our skills – less than 1% of attorneys in New Jersey hold the distinction of being a Certified Criminal Trial Attorney. Don’t risk your future. Call us now for a strong defense.
The Law
The cornerstone of evidence disclosure is the Brady rule, established by the United States Supreme Court. It mandates that prosecutors must disclose exculpatory evidence, which is any evidence that may be favorable to the accused or cast doubt on the credibility of key government witnesses. This ensures a fair trial, as the suppression of such evidence violates the accused’s right to due process. Additionally, the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled that evidence capable of challenging the reliability of a government witness also falls under the umbrella of the Brady rule.
Prosecution Team
The duty to collect and reveal such evidence goes beyond the individual prosecutor handling the case. It extends to the entire prosecution team, encompassing not only prosecutors but also law enforcement officers and other personnel involved in the investigation or prosecution of the case. This means that any team member who discovers potentially favorable evidence must promptly share it with the prosecutor.
Practical Application – Responsibilities Under Brady
Prosecutors possess the authority to determine the scope of evidence covered by the Brady rule and must disclose it to the defense. However, prosecutors rely on investigative employees to provide relevant evidence. It is imperative for investigative employees to be well-versed in the nuances of the Brady rule. If they encounter any uncertainty regarding what evidence should be disclosed, they should consult with the prosecutor for guidance. Ultimately, it falls upon the prosecutor to decide whether or not to disclose potentially exculpatory evidence. In cases where the decision is unclear, prosecutors can seek advice from their supervisors.
Examples Of Brady Material
Here are a few examples of evidence that could be considered Brady material:
Evidence That Links A State Witness To The Crime For Which You Are Being Charged.
For instance, if there is evidence demonstrating the witness’s involvement or connection to the alleged offense.
Evidence Supporting Your Theory Of Another Person’s Guilt.
This could include information indicating that someone else may have committed the crime, thereby casting doubt on your involvement.
Potentially Exculpatory Results From A Polygraph Test Taken By A State Witness.
If a witness undergoes a polygraph examination and the results raise questions about their credibility, this information must be disclosed.
Prior Statements Made By A State Witness That Are Inconsistent With Their Current Testimony And Could Support Your Defense.
If a witness’s earlier statements contradict their current testimony, such discrepancies could significantly impact their credibility.
Responsibilities Under Giglio Relating To Witness Testimony
In addition to the Brady rule, there exists a constitutional requirement to disclose all Giglio material. Giglio material includes impeachment evidence, which is evidence that can impeach the testimony of a government witness, thereby challenging their credibility. It is crucial to note that the State’s obligation to disclose extends beyond evidence that directly proves a defendant’s innocence. It encompasses any information that could influence the credibility of a witness testifying against you.
FAQ
What Is The Brady Rule, And Why Is It Important For Me As A Potential Criminal Defendant?
The Brady rule is a legal requirement that prosecutors must disclose any evidence that could favor the accused or undermine the credibility of key government witnesses. It ensures a fair trial by preventing the suppression of favorable evidence. As a defendant, it’s crucial to understand this rule because it guarantees that potentially helpful evidence is shared with your defense team.
Who Is Responsible For Gathering And Disclosing Brady Material?
The responsibility falls not only on the individual prosecutor handling the case but also on the entire prosecution team. This includes law enforcement officers and other personnel involved in the investigation or prosecution of the case. Any member of the team who becomes aware of potentially favorable evidence must share it with the prosecutor.
What Happens If The Prosecutor Is Not Aware Of Potentially Exculpatory Evidence, But Other Members Of The Prosecution Team Are?
The law imputes knowledge of potential Brady material to the prosecutor. Therefore, it becomes the prosecutor’s responsibility to gather and disclose such evidence, even if they were initially unaware of its existence. The collective knowledge of the prosecution team is imputed to the prosecutor.
Can I Request The Disclosure Of Brady Material, Or Is It The Prosecutor’s Duty To Disclose It Automatically?
As a defendant, you have the right to request the disclosure of Brady material. However, it’s important to note that prosecutors are obligated to disclose such material whether or not you specifically request it. The responsibility lies with the prosecutor to ensure that all potentially exculpatory evidence is disclosed.
What Are Some Examples Of Evidence That Could Be Considered Brady Material?
Brady material can include various types of evidence, such as:
- Evidence linking a state witness to the crime you are being charged with.
- Evidence supporting your theory of another person’s guilt.
- Potentially exculpatory results from a polygraph test taken by a state witness.
- Prior statements made by a state witness that are inconsistent with their current testimony and could support your defense.
Is There A Requirement To Disclose Evidence That Challenges The Credibility Of Government Witnesses?
Yes, there is a constitutional requirement, known as the Giglio rule, to disclose evidence that impeaches the testimony of government witnesses. This includes any information that could affect the credibility of a witness, even if it does not directly establish your innocence. The obligation to disclose extends to evidence that pertains to the witness’s credibility.
What Should I Do If I Suspect There Is Brady Or Giglio Material That Has Not Been Disclosed To My Defense Team?
If you have concerns about the disclosure of Brady or Giglio material, it is important to communicate with your defense attorney. They can evaluate the situation, review the evidence that has been disclosed, and take appropriate legal action if necessary to ensure that all relevant material is provided to your defense. Your attorney will advocate for your rights and work to address any discrepancies or omissions in the evidence disclosure process.
New Jersey Criminal Defense Lawyer
If you’ve been charged with a crime in New Jersey, don’t face it alone. Contact The Law Offices of Jonathan F. Marshall at (877) 534-7338 or online today. Our team of dedicated criminal defense attorneys has the training, knowledge, and experience to stand up against prosecutors and fight for your rights. With over 200 years of combined experience, our firm offers a powerhouse defense that you can rely on. We have a team of 11 attorneys who specialize in criminal law, including seven former prosecutors who understand both sides of the courtroom. Our track record speaks for itself, with multiple attorneys selected to the prestigious National Trial Lawyers Top 100 or Top 40 Under 40. We also have two lawyers recently recognized as Super Lawyers Rising Stars for 2021 in New Jersey, an honor bestowed upon only 2.5% of attorneys in the state.
Additionally, one of our attorneys holds the distinction of being Certified by the New Jersey Supreme Court as a Criminal Trial Attorney, which happens to be a distinction that is achieved by less than 1% of attorneys in the state. Don’t gamble with your future. Call us today for a strong defense that will fight for the most favorable outcome in your case.
Learn more about the criminal process in New Jersey.
